First of all, there’s my current number one Christmas favorite Winter’s Promise by Anna Tabbush. I hope she’ll keep it up on her MySpace page until at least Old Christmas (January 8). It talks about all the commercialization of the season and how “Twelve days of Christmas lasts at least Twelve Weeks”, but it holds out the satisfaction of Parsnips as a consolation. She has posted the recipe for Honey-Roasted Parsnips on her site as well. Rachel Drayson plays cello for the song, and there are the obligatory sleigh bells and angel chorus. It’s just a delight. I still haven’t gotten around to trying the honey-roasted parsnip recipe, but we are eating a lot of parsnips thanks to the root-cellar of our local CSA (I’ll try to write about CSA’s later). Today we’re having apple-parsnip soup.
I’ll always remember the one Christmas I spent in Denmark as a teenager. The Danes have a tradition of secular Christmas songs that celebrate the family issues surrounding the holiday without mentioning Jesus at all, and my favorites include “Hojt fra Traets Groene Top”, which is sung while dancing around the Tree and makes fun of each family member in turn. The most memorable line is “Christmas lasts a long time, costs a lot of money.” “Sikken Volsom Traengsel og Alarm” is about getting ready for Christmas Eve dinner. It talks about high food prices and well-earned relaxation as everybody, even the dog, has to fast until the feast is ready. There is something about these songs that makes them feel more genuine than America’s tin-pan-alley Christmas songs like White Christmas and Rudolph the Red-nosed Reindeer. Of course there are also Lutheran hymns for Christmas, but I got the impression that most Danes were not at all religious in the conventional sense. After all. it’s called by the pagan name Jul rather than “Kristi Fodsesdag.”
The Danish secualar Christmas songs seem to have arisen out of a 19th century music hall tradition combined with a strong old pagan tradition… lots of songs about Nisse (mischevous house elves) and trees. The British/Celtic tradition was similar to the Scandinavian one, with pagan festivals incorporated into the church year as saints days surrounding the solstice, leaving traditions like wassailing and hunting the wren on St. Stephen’s day to stand alongside churchgoing. Since all scholars worthy of the name now agree Jesus was not born in December or January, what’s left as an underpinning to the tradition is an ancient Winter festival season during the time of year when sharing food and drink was essential to survival in an agricultural society, and affirmation of interdependence. This stands in such stark contrast to the free-market consumer festival that now overlays the whole “fourth quarter” of the year. The older festival is consistent with the core teachings of all the world’s great religions; the new one is emphatically not.