I was driving between home and work when I heard Scottish Justice Minister Kenny MacAskill’s voice on radio explaining that convicted aircraft bomber and mass-murderer Abdelbaset al-Megrahi was to be freed from prison on compassionate grounds. I had to pull over because my eyes had filled with tears. I remember the Shakespearean-sounding words “…Justice must be tempered by mercy..” and an eloquent and balanced explanation of how an unrepentant mass-murderer can nevertheless be a frail, dying man, no threat to anyone, who deserves to spend his last days with his family. Since that day, I have heard little else but angry condemnation of the decision in the press, both left and right. More disturbing, I have heard the very concept of compassionate release attacked, particularly in the US press. The US has no consistent legal doctrine of compassionate release, but Britain, including Scotland, does.
I would advocate strongly that the US adopt such a policy, and that it rethink policies such as three-strikes-and-you’re-out that have filled our prisons with aging inmates who are not ever supposed to be released, on the assumption that the suffering of the victims calls for unending vindictiveness toward those who have